Book Review: First Grave on the Right by Darynda Jones

St. Martin’s Press
310 pp.
Buy on Amazon

First Grave on the Right is a urban fantasy/paranormal romance with a thin candy coating of mystery. Our Heroine is a private investigator named Charley Davidson who sees dead people. Or rather, they see her, because she is apparently “the light” you’re supposed to go toward when you die. She is the Grim Reaper, and she is largely responsible for helping first her father and then her uncle become police detectives. (It is super easy to solve murders if you can talk to the victim!)

Our Heroine is awakened by a dead man who is hoping she can solve his murder. Then she gets a call from her uncle for a triple homicide. (The dead man is one of three lawyers, the partners of a small legal firm.) Charley is drawn into the case which involves human trafficking, while she attempts to settle the business of a few of the various ghosts in her life with limited success.

If that were not trouble enough, Charley has been getting visitations from a mysterious figure who has been appearing in her dreams (extremely explicit dreams). This entity may or may not be dead and may or may not be human. She spends a great deal of time obsessing over him in between dodging skeptics and talking to dead people. She spends a great deal of time trying to find out what or who he is, much more time in fact than she actually spends on the case she’s actually getting paid for. (I am deeply unhappy when someone who is supposed to be a professional spends more time with her romantic life than with her career.)    

Our Heroine eventually learns that her mysterious dream-visitor and a much scarier visitation that has haunted her since the day she was born may be connected, but this does not stop her from pursuing him. She is one determined lady, but it’s really too bad she can’t seem to put all that determination into her actual job. (This is illustrated very clearly throughout the book in painful detail.)

This book is a very light, fast read. It does manage to be engaging and the main character is not quite as incompetent as she sometimes appears. (I blame this on the writer occasionally trying to make things that are not actually funny into jokes.) The worldbuilding is somewhat shaky, but that can possibly be attributed to unreliable narrator, since Our Heroine does not really know very much about the supernatural aspects of her world, despite being a supernatural being herself. While the story does have its good moments and it did keep me interested in finding out what happens next.

I did have some problems with the romantic development between Our Heroine and romantic interest. My problem with the romantic development is that it is kind of nonexistent. There is no relationship here, there is just steamy dreams and an occasional ghostly presence and Charley’s obsession with finding out who the guy is.  



Filed under book, Darynda Jones, fantasy, Review: Book, romance, urban

2 responses to “Book Review: First Grave on the Right by Darynda Jones

  1. I didn't like this book, but that's because there was a lot of emphasis on the romantic aspect, which isn't really a genre I usually care for. And it was a bit cliched (smart alec-y fat friend, mother issues, hot main character who eats a lot yet is slim and denigrates aspects of her body, etc). The actual writing was ok, and for people keen on this genre it's most likely a really enjoyable read. I wish there'd been more supernatural and more detectiving and less lust and romance crap. :/

  2. Considering that mother issues are a common real life problem (as well as father issues and older/younger sibling and "oh god my relatives drive me nuts unto the fifth degree" issues) I am not sure mommy issues can be something you'd avoid in your writing as a cliche. Because family dysfunction is a thing that is real, and logically, not every character should come from an ideal home. That said, I really wish it had been handled better. I was also not bothered over much by the main character's ability to eat a lot since technically, she is not human and may have a vastly different metabolism. I would have preferred better worldbuilding in general, and a more indepth characterization. Also, I would have preferred that the romantic aspects actually made emotional sense to me, which it did not.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s